Muhammad: His Life Based on the Earliest Sources
R**D
Amazing and well detailed!
This book on the prophet Muhammad (pbuh) Is well worth waiting for and very detailed about his life. There were quite a few chapters I did not expect but was quite thrilled to read. Also really nice being able to read this during the holy month.I will most likely be coming back to this seller for more of these insightful books on Islamic topics.
T**H
Highly Accurate
For anyone who would like to know more about the life of Prophet Muhammad, this is the book for you. As someone who had read and heard the arabic sources, i can comfortably say that this book is highly accurate and matched most what i already used to know about the life of the Prophet Muhammad. The author just studied and translated all the earliest reliable resources without trying to impose his point of view or give his opinion. He did occasionally leave some commentary here and there to explain some of the pertinent cultural habits or speech of the arabs who lived at that time. The author is not apologetic in any way nor does he try to distort or change the events to make it more appealing to the non-muslims reader. The author's honesty is evident by the fact that he mentioned in great details, and without modifications, all the "sensitive" or "controversial" issues such as the marriages of the Prophet or the wars and fighting that took place. So for any anti-muslim reader or writer, this is the book for you too. Finally, i wish if the author mentioned in more details the Last Sermon of the Prophet during the last pilgrimage. it was really a nice and eloquent speech and would only add one more page to the book. Anyway it can be found on the net just search for it. He also did not mention some of the famous last words of the Prophet before his death, specially when emphasizing about praying and the treatment of women: "By Allah ! the prayer ! the prayer ! and he kept on repeating those words until he said: O people, fear Allah in dealing with women, fear Allah in dealing with women, O people, I ask you to be good to your women".nb: Although this book is considered the most reliable source about the life of Prophet Muhammad, it still surprises me that it had less than 70 reviews, while the book of Robert Spencer, who is neither a schoolar of Islam, nor a speaker of arabic language, got 354 reviews till now..i have no answer for that.
K**A
One of the BEST books about the Prophet. Period.
When I first read this wonderful book by Martin Lings, I felt something I've never experienced before in biographies of early Islam -- a sense that I was actually there, experiencing the drama, tragedy and triumph of the early Muslim community. Lings is an incredibly gifted storyteller who makes you feel like you are an active witness to events unfolding right now, rather than reading 1400-year old stories.Some reviewers have criticized this book because it tells the story of the Prophet's life story without "critical" analysis. What these reviewers are really complaining about is that the book does not start off under the presumption that the Prophet was false in his claim to be the Messenger of God. This is a book that presents the earliest accounts of the Prophet's life, which were passed along by devout Muslims who believed in his Divine inspiration. These early accounts DO contain stories of remarkable miracles and list countless examples of the Prophet's piety and idealism. And, of course, if the Prophet was who he claimed to be, these stories are perfectly plausible as historical events.But if you are a non-Muslim bent on denigrating the Prophet, you have to presume that these stories are myths and hagiographies, because they do not fit into your predetermined worldview. So anyone who accepts them either is an apologist or deluded, and any book presenting these accounts without rejecting them as human inventions must be "uncritical." The truth is that you will approach the Prophet exactly the way you have already decided you want to -- as a believer or an unbeliever regarding his fundamental mission.But as you read this wonderful tale of a remarkable man who single-handedly changed human history, you must ask yourself -- what if, as one billion human beings already know in their hearts, the story is actually true...?
A**R
Comprehensive, traditional account
If you want to hear the traditional Islamic narrative of the life of the Prophet Muhammad, this book delivers. It synthesizes the Classical Arabic sources into a well-organized and extremely detailed account.Despite the good organization of the narrative, the sheer amount of detail can make this a slow read. If you want a breezy narrative, this book isn't for you. If you want the whole story as traditionally believed by Muslims, with all of the details placed in their context, this is for you.
Trustpilot
1 day ago
3 days ago